Pin from the 1991 MLB All-Star Game, hosted at the SkyDome in Toronto. Selected for his seventh midsummer classic, Tony Gwynn started in the leadoff spot for the National League. He went 2-for-4 on the day and scored a run, showing the same consistency at the plate that defined his Hall of Fame career.

The American League won the game 4–2, but Gwynn’s performance reflected why he was regarded as one of baseball’s most reliable hitters. By 1991, he had already collected multiple batting titles and Gold Gloves, and his All-Star appearances had become an annual showcase of his talents.

Disclaimer:

Condition may vary slightly from photos, with unique marks that highlight this item’s authenticity as a career artifact. This item features a silver OVD, verifying its authenticity through the Tony Gwynn Estate. A TRuEST™ authenticator was not on-site to witness its awarding, which is why this item does not carry our gold-level witness-based authentication OVD.

Part of Eternal All-Star, a collection honoring Tony Gwynn’s 15 All-Star appearances with awards, milestone baseballs, game-used gear, and personal keepsakes. This event is the latest chapter in The Realest’s official Tony Gwynn Auction Series following First Inning and Silver Bats, with every piece coming directly from the Gwynn family ensuring true provenance and a direct link to “Mr. Padre” himself.